We all know how powerful stories are. Whether you’re preaching, leading a team, or simply trying to communicate more clearly, stories help people connect, stay engaged, and remember what you say.
The problem is, many of us feel like we’re just not “natural” storytellers.
The good news is that storytelling is a skill you can learn. With intention and practice, anyone can tell better stories that resonate deeply with their audience.
Here are ten practical tips to help you do exactly that.
1. Personal Stories Are Always Best
Stories from your own life carry unmatched power. When you share something you’ve personally experienced, people connect with you as a real person, not just a communicator.
Personal stories build trust and authenticity. Even if you know great stories that happened to others, your own experiences will almost always land better.
2. The More Removed You Are from the Story, the Less Effective It Is
Stories about “a friend” or “someone I heard about” tend to lose emotional impact. The closer you are to the story, the more genuine and compelling it feels.
If you do tell stories about others, make sure you know the details well and have a meaningful connection to the story.
3. Completely Removed Stories Should Be Used Sparingly
Stories you’ve read or heard about but have no personal connection to can still be useful, but they shouldn’t be your foundation.
Used too often, they can feel forced or disconnected. When you use them, make sure they clearly serve your point and don’t distract from it.
4. Don’t Be the Hero of Every Story
People don’t connect with perfection. They connect with honesty.
When telling personal stories, avoid positioning yourself as the hero who always gets it right. Share your struggles, doubts, and failures alongside your wins. Vulnerability builds credibility far more than self-promotion ever could.
5. Keep Stories Short and Focused
Aim for stories that are two to three minutes long unless they are exceptionally engaging. Cut unnecessary details and get to the heart of the story quickly.
Clarity and brevity help people stay focused and make your story more memorable.
6. Place Stories After Your Main Points
One of the best times to tell a story is right after you make a key point. Stories reinforce truth and help people remember what they’ve just heard.
They also re-engage listeners who may have drifted mentally during explanation or teaching.
7. Tell Stories Consistently
The more often you tell stories, the better you get at it. Regular storytelling also helps your audience expect and engage with that rhythm.
Don’t treat stories as filler. Make them a central part of how you communicate.
8. Practice Your Stories Out Loud
Practice allows you to refine wording, remove unnecessary details, and improve flow.
If the first time you tell a story is in front of people, it often comes out rambling or awkward. Practicing out loud builds confidence and clarity.
9. Never Look at Your Notes While Telling a Story
Reading a story from notes instantly breaks connection.
Eye contact and presence matter. Internalize your stories so you can tell them naturally and confidently. If you need a reminder, use a short cue in your notes rather than a script.
10. People Remember Stories More Than Information
You can have the best outline, the strongest points, and the deepest insight—but if you don’t tell stories, people won’t remember much of it.
Stories humanize your message, create emotional connection, and make truth accessible. This is why Jesus taught in parables. Stories stick.
Final Thoughts
Storytelling isn’t just a nice skill. It’s essential for anyone who wants to communicate effectively, especially when leading people or sharing the gospel.
You don’t have to be naturally gifted. By focusing on personal stories, practicing intentionally, and communicating with authenticity, you can become a better storyteller who helps your message truly land.
At Mission Support, we help churches like yours streamline operations, improve communication, and build stronger teams. Whether it’s branding, strategic planning, or website development, we partner with pastors so they can focus on what matters most.
Need help getting your systems in place? Let’s talk.👉 Click HERE to set up a meeting.
Hungry for more?
This post is just the tip of the iceberg. Most of this content comes straight from our Practical Church Podcast—a bi-weekly show packed with real-world insights, honest conversations, and practical solutions for life in and around the Church.
🎧 Catch the full episode here → Watch Now